counter easy hit Skip to content

The Debut Review: Julianne Moore Goes Full Method, and It's a Riot

I haven't giggled this much in a movie theater in ages. Not polite chuckling, either. I mean the kind of laughing where you glance at the stranger two seats over to make sure they're laughing, too. (They were.)

The Debut, written and directed by Jesse Eisenberg, is a musical-comedy rolled into one. It's also a showcase for Julianne Moore at her absolute best. If you're a fan, stop reading and go buy a ticket. If you need a little more convincing, stick around.

Moore plays Mona Friedman, a shy, overlooked housewife whose family barely notices she's there. Her husband talks past her. Her kids treat her like furniture. Life is quiet and small, and you get the sense she stopped expecting more a long time ago.

Then she lands a bit part at her local community theater. It's a tiny role, the kind most people would treat as a fun hobby. Mona does not treat it as a fun hobby.

The Debut / IMDb

What begins as a minor gig becomes a full-blown obsession. Mona turns into a zealous method actor, determined to protect the artistic integrity of a character most of the audience will barely remember. She studies, commits, and refuses to compromise. Soon she is at war with the show's domineering director, played by Paul Giamatti, and neither will back down.

It's a simple setup, and that's part of the charm. The stakes are ridiculously low, which makes Mona's intensity even funnier.

There's already Oscar buzz around this performance, and after seeing it, I get it. Moore takes Mona from timid and mousy to fearless and slightly unhinged, and she makes every step of that change believable. One minute you feel sorry for her. The next, you're cackling at how far she's willing to go for a role with maybe three lines.

What impressed me most is that she never plays Mona as a joke. Even at her most absurd, there's a real woman underneath, someone who finally found a place where people see her. That's what keeps the comedy from feeling cheap.

Paul Giamatti is the perfect sparring partner. His director is pompous, controlling, and utterly convinced of his own genius, and watching him butt heads with Moore is pure joy. These two clearly had fun, and that energy jumps right off the screen.

The supporting cast is stacked. Halle Bailey (not Halle Berry) brings warmth and that voice. Bernadette Peters, a true Broadway legend, adds instant class to every scene she's in. Colton Ryan holds his own nicely, too. Jesse Eisenberg also pops up on screen, which is impressive given that he wrote, directed, and wrote the songs.

I'll admit I didn't expect Jesse Eisenberg to be the guy behind a movie musical. But here we are, and it works. The music, by Emile Mosseri with songs from Eisenberg, is catchy and clever without ever slowing things down. The choreography comes from Andy Blankenbuehler, the man behind the moves in Hamilton, so the dance numbers have real polish and punch.

The musical moments feel like a natural part of Mona's world. Of course, this story bursts into song. It's about community theater, after all.

The Debut / IMDb

Here's my one real gripe. The first half of The Debut is light, breezy, and laugh-out-loud funny. Then the movie takes a darker, more intense turn, and the shift caught me off guard. It pulled me out of the story for a bit.

As Mona digs deeper into her character, her behavior gets more extreme. At times, it felt almost manic, like she couldn't switch it off. I kept asking myself if a regular person would really go to those lengths for a community theater role. I'm honestly not sure they would.

I understand why she does it. Mona is escaping. Her husband and kids don't respect her, and this role is the first thing in years that belongs only to her. That idea hit home, and I think a lot of people will see themselves in it. But in my view, the movie pushed it a little over the top before pulling back.

The good news? It's temporary. The film finds its footing again, and by the end I was right back on Mona's side.

The Debut is funny, heartfelt, a little strange, and anchored by one of Julianne Moore's most entertaining performances in years. The darker middle stretch might throw you for a moment, but it doesn't take away from how much fun this movie is overall.

If you're a Julianne Moore fan, you'll love every minute. I caught it on the big screen, and I'm so glad I did. Comedy just hits harder with a full room laughing along with you.

So don't wait for streaming. Go see it in a theater before it's gone. Mona would want you to.


Discover more at Frank's Film Review. Click here.

Comments

Latest

Advertisement
Frank's Film Review
Advertisement - Northwest WA State
Example Brand 50% Off Sale Banner
Advertisement
Example Brand 50% Off Sale Banner
Advertisement - Washington State
Wenatchee Insurance